Certificates That Do Real Work: Five Checks Before Site Access
Photo: Thomas Nugent , CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
An insurance certificate is not proof that a risk has been transferred. It is proof that a policy exists at a point in time, on the terms set out in the policy and any endorsements. On UK commercial projects, the distance between those two statements is where disputes begin. The certificate should therefore act as a gate: no site access, no instruction to mobilise and no payment milestone until the required cover is demonstrated by the policy schedule and endorsements, not merely by a one-page summary.
Read the contract before the certificate
The contract sets the insurance standard. The certificate should be checked against that standard, not against a generic checklist. Confirm the required classes, limits, duration, insured parties and extensions. Identify whether the requirement is for a project-specific policy or an annual policy with project extensions. If the contract requires cover for a particular period, check that the policy period and any extension match it.
Test one: named insureds and interested parties
Names matter. A certificate showing a trading name, a parent company or a joint venture label may not identify the legal entity that carries the contractual obligation. Check the exact company name, company number where available, and the project description. Confirm whether the client, contractor, funder or other interested party is an additional insured, a co-insured or merely noted on the certificate. Those are different positions. If the contract requires primary and non-contributory cover, confirm that the endorsement says so.
Test two: endorsed extensions
A certificate may list extensions that are standard to the policy but not effective for the project. The useful question is whether the extension is endorsed and applies to the named insured and the project. Check site cover, temporary works, existing structures, pollution or contamination where relevant, and any contract-specific extension. A generic reference to cover is not the same as an endorsement. Where the policy excludes a risk that the contract allocates to the insured party, record the gap and close it before mobilisation.
Test three: waiver of subrogation
A waiver of subrogation prevents an insurer from recovering a loss from another party after paying a claim. It is commercially important where the client, contractor and subcontractors share a site and a risk. Check that the waiver is endorsed, that it identifies the parties in whose favour it operates, and that it is consistent with the contract's insurance clause. A waiver in one policy is of limited use if the other party's policy does not recognise it.
Test four: excess layers and aggregates
A certificate may show the primary layer and omit the excess layers that actually meet the contractual limit. Ask for a schedule of all layers, including limits, aggregates, deductibles and any erosion of limits by claims. Check whether the layers follow form and whether any layer carries an exclusion that undermines the cover. Confirm how aggregate limits apply across projects and whether the project has a dedicated limit. A high headline limit can be misleading if it is heavily eroded or subject to a large deductible.
Test five: subcontractor cover
Subcontractor insurance should not be assumed from the main contractor's certificate. Confirm that each subcontractor carries the required cover, that the limits and extensions match the subcontract, and that the policy period covers the subcontract works. Check employer's liability cover, public liability, contract works and any professional indemnity requirement. Where subcontractors rely on their own annual policies, record renewal dates and require evidence of renewal before expiry.
Make the gate operational
A certificate register should record the requirement, the evidence received, the reviewer, the date and any open query. Diarise expiry and renewal. Use a hold point before site access and before payment where the contract allows. If the evidence is incomplete, say so in writing and state what is needed. The aim is not to create a filing exercise. It is to make sure that the insurance position is known, owned and closed before the project depends on it.